Sources of Large Firms’ Market Power and Why It Matters
Filippo di Mauro, Matthias Mertens, Bernardo Mottironi
VOXEU COLUMN,
January
2023
Abstract
Excessive market power has detrimental effects on the functioning of the economy, raising consumer prices, distorting the allocation of resources, and creating welfare losses. The existing literature has largely focussed on competition in product markets. This column argues that it is important to differentiate between various sources of firm market power on output and input (most notably labour) markets. European firm-level data reveals that large firms charge lower markups in product markets but exert their market power significantly in labour markets. Competition authorities can and must distinguish between the sources of market power when attempting to regulate it.
Artikel Lesen
Do Larger Firms Exert More Market Power? Markups and Markdowns along the Size Distribution
Matthias Mertens, Bernardo Mottironi
IWH-CompNet Discussion Papers,
Nr. 1,
2023
Abstract
Several models posit a positive cross-sectional correlation between markups and firm size, which characterizes misallocation, factor shares, and gains from trade. Accounting for labor market power in markup estimation, we find instead that larger firms have lower product markups but higher wage markdowns. The negative markup-size correlation turns positive when conditioning on markdowns, suggesting interactions between product and labor market power. Our findings are robust to common criticism (e.g., price bias, non-neutral technology) and hold across 19 European countries. We discuss possible mechanisms and resulting implications, highlighting the importance of studying input and output market power in a unified framework.
Artikel Lesen
Do Larger Firms Exert More Market Power? Markups and Markdowns along the Size Distribution
Matthias Mertens, Bernardo Mottironi
IWH Discussion Papers,
Nr. 1,
2023
Abstract
Several models posit a positive cross-sectional correlation between markups and firm size, which characterizes misallocation, factor shares, and gains from trade. Accounting for labor market power in markup estimation, we find instead that larger firms have lower product markups but higher wage markdowns. The negative markup-size correlation turns positive when conditioning on markdowns, suggesting interactions between product and labor market power. Our findings are robust to common criticism (e.g., price bias, non-neutral technology) and hold across 19 European countries. We discuss possible mechanisms and resulting implications, highlighting the importance of studying input and output market power in a unified framework.
Artikel Lesen
A Note on the Use of Syndicated Loan Data
Isabella Müller, Felix Noth, Lena Tonzer
IWH Discussion Papers,
Nr. 17,
2022
Abstract
Syndicated loan data provided by DealScan has become an essential input in banking research over recent years. This data is rich enough to answer urging questions on bank lending, e.g., in the presence of financial shocks or climate change. However, many data options raise the question of how to choose the estimation sample. We employ a standard regression framework analyzing bank lending during the financial crisis to study how conventional but varying usages of DealScan affect the estimates. The key finding is that the direction of coefficients remains relatively robust. However, statistical significance seems to depend on the data and sampling choice.
Artikel Lesen
The Value of Firm Networks: A Natural Experiment on Board Connections
Ester Faia, Maximilian Mayer, Vincenzo Pezone
SAFE Working Papers,
Nr. 269,
2022
Abstract
We present causal evidence on the effect of boardroom networks on firm value and compensation policies. We exploit a ban on interlocking directorates of Italian financial and insurance companies as exogenous variation and show that firms that lose centrality in the network experience negative abnormal returns around the announcement date. The key driver of our results is the role of boardroom connections in reducing asymmetric information. The complementarities with the input-output and cross-ownership networks are consistent with this channel. Using hand-collected data, we also show that network centrality has a positive effect on directors’ compensation, providing evidence of rent sharing.
Artikel Lesen
Globalization, Productivity Growth, and Labor Compensation
Christian Dreger, Marius Fourné, Oliver Holtemöller
IWH Discussion Papers,
Nr. 7,
2022
Abstract
We analyze how changes in international trade integration affect productivity and the functional income distribution. To account for endogeneity, we construct a leaveout measure for international trade integration for country-industry pairs using international input-output tables. Our findings corroborate on the country-industry level that international trade integration increases productivity. Moreover, we show that both trade in intermediate inputs and trade in value added is associated with lower labor shares in emerging markets. For advanced countries, we document a positive effect of trade in value added on the labor share of income. Further, we show that the effects on productivity and labor share are heterogeneous across different sectors. Finally, we discuss the implications of our results for a possible throwback in international trade integration due to experiences from recent crises.
Artikel Lesen
International Trade Barriers and Regional Employment: The Case of a No-Deal Brexit
Hans-Ulrich Brautzsch, Oliver Holtemöller
Journal of Economic Structures,
Nr. 11,
2021
Abstract
We use the World Input–Output Database (WIOD) combined with regional sectoral employment data to estimate the potential regional employment effects of international trade barriers. We study the case of a no-deal Brexit in which imports to the United Kingdom (UK) from the European Union (EU) would be subject to tariffs and non-tariff trade costs. First, we derive the decline in UK final goods imports from the EU from industry-specific international trade elasticities, tariffs and non-tariff trade costs. Using input–output analysis, we estimate the potential output and employment effects for 56 industries and 43 countries on the national level. The absolute effects would be largest in big EU countries which have close trade relationships with the UK, such as Germany and France. However, there would also be large countries outside the EU which would be heavily affected via global value chains, such as China, for example. The relative effects (in percent of total employment) would be largest in Ireland followed by Belgium. In a second step, we split up the national effects on the NUTS-2 level for EU member states and additionally on the county (NUTS-3) level for Germany. The share of affected workers varies between 0.03% and 3.4% among European NUTS-2 regions and between 0.15% and 0.4% among German counties. A general result is that indirect effects via global value chains, i.e., trade in intermediate inputs, are more important than direct effects via final demand.
Artikel Lesen
Conditional Macroeconomic Forecasts: Disagreement, Revisions and Forecast Errors
Alexander Glas, Katja Heinisch
IWH Discussion Papers,
Nr. 7,
2021
Abstract
Using data from the European Central Bank‘s Survey of Professional Forecasters, we analyse the role of ex-ante conditioning variables for macroeconomic forecasts. In particular, we test to which extent the heterogeneity, updating and ex-post performance of predictions for inflation, real GDP growth and the unemployment rate are related to assumptions about future oil prices, exchange rates, interest rates and wage growth. Our findings indicate that inflation forecasts are closely associated with oil price expectations, whereas expected interest rates are used primarily to predict output growth and unemployment. Expectations about exchange rates and wage growth also matter for macroeconomic forecasts, albeit less so than oil prices and interest rates. We show that survey participants can considerably improve forecast accuracy for macroeconomic outcomes by reducing prediction errors for external conditions. Our results contribute to a better understanding of the expectation formation process of experts.
Artikel Lesen
Die veränderten Wettbewerbsbedingungen von Nordrhein-Westfalen durch ein verändertes ‚level-playing-field‘ in den Wirtschaftsbeziehungen zum Vereinigten Königreich und Nordirland
Hans-Ulrich Brautzsch, Andrej Drygalla, Oliver Holtemöller, Martina Kämpfe, Axel Lindner
IWH Studies,
Nr. 1,
2021
Abstract
Am 31.01.2020 ist das Vereinigte Königreich Großbritannien und Nordirland (Großbritannien) aus der Europäischen Union (EU) ausgetreten. Das Land ist bisher als Handelspartner der nordrhein-westfälischen Wirtschaft von erheblicher Bedeutung gewesen: 2015, im Jahr vor dem britischen Volksentscheid zugunsten eines Austritts, war es mit einem Anteil von 7,7% der drittwichtigste Absatzmarkt für Warenexporte aus Nordrhein-Westfalen, und immerhin 4,6% aller Warenimporte stammten aus Großbritannien. In der vorliegenden Studie werden die Konsequenzen des Brexit für das Land Nordrhein-Westfalen erörtert. Der Fokus liegt dabei auf der kurzen bis mittleren Frist, denn das zentrale Instrument der Analyse, die Input-Output-Rechnung, nutzt Informationen über gegenwärtige Wirtschaftsstrukturen, die sich an die nach dem Austritt Großbritanniens neuen Rahmenbedingungen im Lauf der Zeit anpassen werden. Die Perspektiven für die wirtschaftlichen Beziehungen zwischen Großbritannien und der EU, wie sie sich im Frühjahr 2020 darstellen, werden am Anfang der Studie (Abschnitt 2) skizziert. Daran schließt sich ein Überblick der Literatur zu den wirtschaftlichen Folgen des Brexit für Europa, für Deutschland und für einzelne Regionen an (Abschnitt 3). Das zentrale Kapitel der Studie (Abschnitt 4) beleuchtet die Effekte des Brexit auf die Wirtschaft Nordrhein-Westfalens. Dabei geht es vor allem um den Güterhandel, die Produktion und die Beschäftigung, aber auch um Effekte auf Investitionen und Arbeitsproduktivität. Um auch wichtige indirekte Effekte über Vorleistungsbeziehungen zu erfassen, kommt die Input-Output-Analyse zum Einsatz. Nach einer kurzen Darstellung der Wirtschaftsstruktur Nordrhein-Westfalens und der Handelsverflechtungen zwischen Großbritannien, Deutschland und der EU werden die kurz- bis mittelfristigen Effekte des Brexit auf den Güterhandel, die Produktion und die Beschäftigung in Deutschland und in neun nordrhein-westfälischen Regionen simuliert. An die so erzielten Ergebnisse schließen sich qualitative Überlegungen zu den Effekten auf Investitionstätigkeit und Produktivitätsentwicklung an. In Abschnitt 5 wird diskutiert, ob sich mit dem Brexit nicht auch Chancen für die Wirtschaft Nordrhein-Westfalens bieten. Zu diesem Zweck wird untersucht, in welchen Branchen sowohl Großbritannien als auch Nordrhein-Westfalen bisher innerhalb der EU komparative Vorteile gehabt haben, und ob der Austritt Großbritanniens dort Marktanteilsgewinne der heimischen Wirtschaft ermöglichen könnte. In Abschnitt 6 wird der Frage nachgegangen, welche Instrumente und Maßnahmen von der Politik genutzt werden könnten, um einen fairen und regelbasierten Wettbewerb auf Basis des bisherigen ‚level-playing-field‘ zwischen nordrhein-westfälischen und britischen Unternehmen zu gewährleisten. In einem abschließenden Abschnitt 7 werden die wichtigsten Ergebnisse der Studie zusammengefasst.
Artikel Lesen
Regional Effects of Professional Sports Franchises – Causal Evidence from Four European Football Leagues
Matthias Brachert
Regional Studies,
Nr. 2,
2021
Abstract
The locational pattern of clubs in four professional football leagues in Europe is used to test the causal effect of relegations on short-run regional development. The study relies on the relegation mode of the classical round-robin tournament in the European model of sport to develop a regression-discontinuity design. The results indicate small and significant negative short-term effects on regional employment and output in the sports-related economic sector. In addition, small negative effects on overall regional employment growth are found. Total regional gross value added remains unaffected.
Artikel Lesen