Municipal Enterprises as Shadow Budgets – How do they Affect the Actual Budgetary Situation of Germany´s Local Governments?
Peter Haug
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 5,
2009
Abstract
Outsourcing of municipal tasks from the core budget to municipal enterprises tends to distort the perception of the actual financial position, net assets and results of operations of the German local governments. Excess supply or -demand of/for local public services might be possible consequences of this development. Hence, this article attempts to develop a more comprehensive picture of the municipal budgetary position by a simultaneous analysis of selected indicators. Furthermore, the methodological problems of the calculations are illustrated.
If these shadow budgets are taken into account, the total per capita revenues, -investments and -debts will increase by approximately one third to 50%. However, the share of the municipal employees belonging to the core administration in the total number of municipal employees is 75%. Although only about 22% of the expenditures for certain voluntary municipal tasks have been outsourced, there seems to be an upward trend.
The study also indicates that there are significant differences between Eastern and Western German cities. These include the higher revenues from municipal enterprises, the higher debts per capita and the higher expenditures on culture, sports, leisure services or the promotion of science in Eastern Germany.
The results should be interpreted carefully due to some shortcomings of the official statistics. For example, internal cash flows cannot be totally eliminated. Moreover, indirect municipal majority holdings as well as the municipal savings banks are not included in the results.
All in all, it remains to be seen whether the initiated reforms concerning the introduction of double-entry accounting into the local government budgeting system will help to achieve the ideal goal of a meaningful “consolidated financial statement” for the “city company”.
Read article
Parenting Benefit – A New Risk for Companies
Nicole Nulsch, Henry Dannenberg
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 7,
2008
Abstract
One of the aims of the new parenting benefit – introduced by the German government in January 2007 – is to motivate fathers to take parental leave in order to take care of their young children. Until now, the effects of the parenting benefit have been discussed predominantly from the viewpoint of family policy. In contrast, this paper analyses how companies are affected by the new law. In 2007, the number of fathers who stayed at home to spend more time with their children increased significantly. More than half of the working applicants were already fathers. In the past, it was easy for companies to reduce their risk of losing an important employee due to the birth of a child as companies rather hired men than women. But this strategy will be less important in the future. It is expected that the risk-environment of companies will change because of a larger group of fathers taking parental leave. Such a changed risk-environment could increase the career opportunities of women and might reduce the gender wage gap. However, it is also expected that the overall risk of companies increases. Assumed that companies need equity to cover risks, an increase of the overall risk reduces investment opportunities if it is not possible to increase equity in the same way. This could influence the current economic development negatively.
Read article
Russia: Ongoing Strong Economic Growth Overshadowed by High Inflation
Martina Kämpfe
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 6,
2008
Abstract
Russian economic growth in 2007 again was driven by strong private consumption and investment, grew by double-digit rates. The roles of budget expenditures and borrowing of private and state-owned firms from abroad in financing investments increased rapidly. Russian inflation climbed again; it was driven up by increases in food prices in line with rising food prices around the world. Inflation pressures had sharpened through more budget spending and scheduled rate increases for electricity and gas as well as for regulated prices for municipal services. Broad money supply (M2) rose rapidly because of strong foreign currency inflows, too. Central bank seeks to bring inflation under control by tightening monetary policy this year. That will somewhat dampen economic growth, but nevertheless GDP growth in the near future will remain at high levels.
Read article
Revenue Boosting Instruments in Municipal Finance from a Public Choice Perspective
Peter Haug
Diamond, J. (ed.), Proceedings. 98th Annual Conference on Taxation, Miami, Florida, November 17-19, 2005 and Minutes of the Annual Meeting of the National Tax Association, Thrusday, November 17, 2005,
2006
Abstract
German municipalities are currently struggling with growing budget deficits, decreasing revenues, and rising expenditures. We argue that from a public choice perspective local politicians under financial pressure might prefer fiscal instruments that minimize the local voters' resistance and create fiscal illusion. According to Germany, suitable sources of additional revenues include the reallocation of revenues from the local business tax between the levels of government and increased profitability of local public utilities. Revenue Data from 1992 to 2004 indicate that changes in the relative significance of the net local business tax revenues are rather caused by changes in the share of the federal government in the revenues ('Gewerbesteuerumlage') than by changes in the local tax multipliers. Furthermore, we find a significant rise in profits of local public utilities in large German cities.
Read article
Fiscal economy potentials of a county structure reform in Saxony-Anhalt
Simone Scharfe
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 5,
2006
Abstract
In view of the foreseeable demographic and finance-political developments the public house holds of Eastern Germany are under considerable strain to consolidate. This applies particularly to Saxony-Anhalt and there especially to local authorities. In 2003 the municipal expenses level (running material expenses and personnel expenses) of counties and communities in Saxony-Anhalt amounted 1,015 Euro per inhabitant and was clearly higher than the other East German states. Beyond the means of economisation through the efficient application of public funds, considerations are given to the potentials of country structure reforms. In the last legislative period, the CDU/FDP government already established the amalgamation of 24 counties to eleven new ones with the bill of 11.11.2005. The SPD - as an oppositional party at that time - submitted a proposal for an even further-reaching structural change with a concentration to five counties. This article comprises an estimation of the fiscal economisation potentials of both versions. In the first step, the (long term accessible) county expense levels of Saxony-Anhalt within the scope of the existing structure of a county is determined with the help of a Benchmarkanalysis. These results are then compared with expected expense levels of a reformed county structure which leads to the saving effect of the respective county reform. In the result of the analysis it appears that the suggestion of the SPD to the county structure reform allows to expect clearly higher saving effects than the suggestion of the former CDU/FDP government, a strong meaning of the already enforced community administrative reform is imputable.
Read article
Benchmarking-Report Mecklenburg-Vorpommern -Öffentliche Aufgabenerfüllung im Ländervergleich-
Joachim Ragnitz, Helmut Seitz
One-off Publications,
No. 8,
2005
Abstract
Vor dem Hintergrund der gegenwärtig höchst angespannten Haushaltslage und den sich langfristig aus der Rückführung der Osttransfers und dem demographischen Wandel ergebenden Anpassungsproblemen untersucht dieser Bericht den finanzpolitischen Handlungsbedarf des Landes Mecklenburg-Vorpommern und seiner Gemeinden. Das hierbei verwendete methodische Instrument ist ein „Benchmarking-Ansatz“, bei dem mit Hilfe von Vergleichsdaten Auffälligkeiten bei den Einnahmen, den Ausgaben und beim Personalbesatz untersucht werden. Als Vergleichsmaßstab wird der Durchschnitt der finanzschwachen Westflächenländer (FFW), bestehend aus den Ländern Nieder-sachsen (NI), Rheinland-Pfalz (RP), Saarland (SL) und Schleswig-Holstein (SH) sowie – um Ostaspekte adäquat zu berücksichtigen – der Freistaat Sachsen (SN) herangezogen.
Read article
The new social benefits scheme (Arbeitslosengeld II) and the Municipal Option Act
Herbert Buscher
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 9,
2004
Abstract
One of the most important reform measures of the German labor market relates to the harmonization of social welfare and unemployment assistence to the new ‘”Arbeitslosengeld-II”. In the context of these reform measures it is expected that local employment offices and local authorities should constitute working parties to facilitate the unemployed in finding new jobs. In the case that a local authority prefers to manage this job in its own responsibility she has the right to opt. The paper discusses possible advantages and disadvantages of this option.
Read article
Cross subsidization of municipal services in Germany: Current importance and evaluation with respect to efficiency and distribution
Peter Haug
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 9,
2003
Abstract
rotz Liberalisierung des Energiemarktes und der absehbaren Deregulierung des Öffentlichen Personennahverkehrs (ÖPNV) innerhalb der EU hat die Quersubventionierung des Nahverkehrs über die Gewinne der kommunalen Versorgungsunternehmen nach wie vor eine große quantitative Bedeutung in Deutschland. Dies belegt eine Erhebung des IWH in deutschen Großstädten. Diese Praxis kann aus wohlfahrtsökonomischer Sicht und aus der Verteilungsperspektive als ineffizient bzw. nicht mit den üblichen Vorstellungen von Bedarfsgerechtigkeit vereinbar beurteilt werden. Soll aus politischen Gründen das ÖPNV-Angebot im bisherigen Umfang aufrechterhalten werden, wäre unter Umständen eine alternative Finanzierungsform geboten.
Read article
Quersubventionen in kommunalen Unternehmen: Praxis und theoretische Wertung?
Peter Haug
List-Forum für Wirtschafts- und Finanzpolitik,
No. 3,
2003
Abstract
Trotz formeller Liberalisierung des Energiemarktes und der absehbaren Deregulierung des Öffentlichen Personennahverkehrs (ÖPNV) innerhalb der EU hat die Quersubventionierung des öffentlichen Nahverkehrs über die Gewinne der Versorgungsunternehmen nach wie vor eine große quantitative Bedeutung. Dies belegt eine Erhebung in deutschen Großstädten, die nach fast 10 Jahren erstmals wieder aktuelle Daten zum Ausmaß der Subventionierung liefert. Selbst wenn die Leistungserstellung der Kommunen in beiden Bereichen grundsätzlich nicht in Frage gestellt würde, liefert die theoretische Diskussion sowohl unter allokativen als auch unter distributiven Gesichtspunkten keine Rechtfertigung für diese Praxis der kommunalen Preisgestaltung. Soll aus politischen Gründen das ÖPNV-Angebot im bisherigen Umfang aufrechterhalten werden, so wäre eine alternative Form der Subventionierung geboten, beispielsweise in Form von direkten personenbezogenen Beihilfen finanziert aus allgemeinen Steuermitteln.
Read article
Current trends – Municipal finances in East Germany: Considerable decline of investment spending; no improvements of revenues
Jens Müller
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 10,
2001
Abstract
Read article
