Real Estate Prices and Bank Stability
Michael Koetter, Tigran Poghosyan
Journal of Banking and Finance,
No. 34,
2010
Abstract
Real estate prices can deviate from their fundamental value due to rigid supply, heterogeneity in quality, and various market imperfections, which have two contrasting effects on bank stability. Higher prices increase the value of collateral and net wealth of borrowers and thus reduce the likelihood of credit defaults. In contrast, persistent deviations from fundamentals may foster the adverse selection of increasingly risky creditors by banks seeking to expand their loan portfolios, which increases bank distress probabilities. We test these hypotheses using unique data on real estate markets and banks in Germany. House price deviations contribute to bank instability, but nominal house price developments do not. This finding corroborates the importance of deviations from the fundamental value of real estate, rather than just price levels or changes alone, when assessing bank stability.
Read article
Keeping the Bubble Alive! The Effects of Urban Renewal and Demolition Subsidies in the East German Housing Market
Dominik Weiß
IWH Discussion Papers,
No. 11,
2009
Abstract
German urban renewal programs are favoring the cities in the Eastern part since the re-unification in 1990. This was accompanied additionally by attractive tax incentives, designed as an accelerated declining balance method of depreciation for housing investments during the late 1990s. The accumulated needs for comfortable housing after 40 years of a disastrous housing policy of the GDR era were generally accepted as justification for the subvention policy. But various subsidies and tax incentives caused a construction boom, false allocations, and a price bubble in Eastern Germany. After recognizing that the expansion of housing supply was not in line with the demographic development and that high vacancy rates were jeopardizing housing companies and their financial backers, policy changed in 2001. Up to now, the government provides demolition grants to reduce the vast oversupply. By means of a real option approach, it is ex-plained how different available forms of subsidies and economic incentives for landlords lift real estate values. The option value representing growth expectations and opportunities is calculated as an observable market value less an estimated fundamental value. Empirical results disclose higher option premiums for cities in Eastern Germany and a strong correlation of the option premium with urban renewal spending.
Read article
Editorial
Ulrich Blum
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 4,
2009
Abstract
Hat der Staat mit dem „Enteignungsgesetz“ den Rubikon überschritten? „Alea iacta est“, die Würfel sind geworfen – noch nicht gefallen, man kann noch zurück. Aber auch Cäsar kehrte nicht um, er stellte die Systemfrage! Es gab frühzeitig eine Vielzahl ordnungsökonomisch verträglicher Vorschläge, beispielsweise einer „chirurgischen Abspaltung mit strategischer Insolvenz“ aus dem IWH, wie das Problem Hypo Real Estate (HRE) bewältigt werden könnte, die auch in Berlin weiterentwickelt wurden. Aber die drastische Sicht der Dinge hat sich durchgesetzt. Wichtigste gegenwärtige Aufgabe wird es sein, künftige Übertreibungen beim Eingriff in die Marktkräfte – der Staat kann und darf alles – einzudämmen. Denn die Herausforderungen werden noch wachsen: Bleibt die bisherige Geldpolitik weitgehend unwirksam, dann wird sich die Frage nach dem Einsatz unkonventioneller Instrumente stellen, die im angelsächsischen Bereich bereits genutzt werden. Falls Staaten in Schieflage gerieten, müssten Summen bewegt werden, die ein Mehrfaches der Anstrengung zur Rettung der HRE betragen.
Read article
Eastern German Economy: No Catching-up in 2008 and 2009
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 6,
2008
Abstract
In the New Lander, growth of production is characterized by two diverging developments. On the one hand, the manufacturing sector has expanded strongly while the public service sector as well as the retail sectors has considerably damped economic activity. On the other hand, those firms primarily bound to local markets have gained hardly any momentum, whereas others have been stimulated by external markets in Western Germany and abroad. These differences are mainly due to weak local demand in the wake of a low purchasing power and an ongoing reduction in the population. At the same time, export-oriented firms in the manufacturing sector have benefited from strong external demand, and they will further benefit from it, although somewhat less owing to the slowing world economy. However, as East German exporting firms are less exposed to those countries where the ongoing crisis in the real estate and the financial sector has unfolded its dampening effects the most, they are also less prone to it. Accordingly, gross domestic product will increase by 1,7% this year and 0,8% in 2009. This translates into further improvements on labor markets. Registered unemployment will fall below one million. In particular, manufacturing firms and the private business service sector will increase their demand for labor.
Read article
Real Options of Private House Owners in the East German Housing Market – How Demolition Subsidies Affect Investment Prospects for Private House Owners
Dominik Weiß
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 6,
2008
Abstract
The subsidies of the German urban renewal program “Stadtumbau Ost” are claimed mainly by communal and cooperative housing companies. The instruments do not fit very well for private proprietors that hold a great part of the older housing stock in central locations, for example in Wilhelminian style districts. Interim evaluation reports concerning the implementation of the “Stadtumbau” program show good results for big housing blocks, but constantly high vacancy rates in the inner city quarters. It becomes obvious that the political targets have not been achieved completely so far and that market forces limit the extensive restoration of historic buildings.
The opportunities, economic incentives and the decisions of landlords and house owners will be analyzed with a real option approach. A detailed view considers the different available forms of subsidies, examining its power to affect real estate values and to initiate politically desired urban transformations. It can be shown that the current forms of subsidies fail to promote investment of private house owners because of rising value expectations. Downgrading the building zones to lower density might reduce unrealistic expectations that were identified as a hurdle to invest. As a consequence from this consideration, municipalities should implement alternative urban development concepts and adjust the subsidy policy.
Read article
Das Programm „Stadtumbau Ost“ und seine wirtschaftlichen Effekte für die beteiligten Städte
Claus Michelsen, Martin T. W. Rosenfeld
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 6,
2007
Abstract
Political measures in the field of urban development have relevant impacts on the local and regional economy, for example on private investment, the value of real estate or the image of a city. An evaluation of national (federal) programs for the support of urban development would not be complete without considering these impacts. For the measures, which are supported by the federal program for support on “Urban Redevelopment in East Germany” (“Stadtumbau Ost”), the economic conditions of the supported cities have played, so far, only a minor role. One expression for this is that the measures for demolishing (“Rückbau”) were concentrated on quarters with prefabricated buildings. From the perspective of local and regional economic development, there have also been failures in the allocation of money for increasing the value of real estate (“Aufwertung”), as the article shows for the example of the state of Saxony.
Read article
Die Lage der Weltwirtschaft und der deutschen Wirtschaft im Frühjahr 2007
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
1. Sonderausgabe
2007
Abstract
In spring 2007, the global economy remains robust. While growth rates have declined slightly from last year, as business activity in the US has slowed, they continue to reflect an upswing, which by now has held on for a notably long time. Especially the developing and emerging countries have been raising output very fast, due in part to their increasing role in the international division of labour. In the industrialised economies, on the other hand, the current recovery has not been remarkably strong. So far the slowdown in the US economy has not spilled over to other regions and the Euro Area as well as Japan continue to expand at a high pace. Here expansive monetary policy provided a notable support. Buoyant financial markets stimulated the world economy additionally, even though market volatility has increased since the end of February. The US central bank’s current concern with inflationary risks keeps it from loosening its slightly restrictive monetary policy. It will be the second half of the year – when price pressures have eased – until the Fed makes its first rate cut. The ECB, on the other hand, has been preparing financial markets for a further increase in interest rates by summer. In 2007 and 2008 the growth disparities in the industrialised countries will diminish. On one hand, the upswing in the Euro Area will start to moderate, as fiscal policy hampers business activity and monetary policy will not stimulate anymore. On the other hand, the US economy will slowly gain pace from summer onwards; the emerging markets will continue to develop in a highly dynamic fashion. World-GDP in this and next year will likely rise by about 3 ¼ % in 2007, which is still faster than in the average of the last ten years. World trade will rise by 7 ½ % in the coming two years. An oil price of 65 US-Dollar and an exchange rate between the Euro and the US-Dollar of 1.32 were assumed for both years 2007 and 2008. The real estate market in the USA continues to be a risk for...
Read article
Ein kubischer Spline zur temporalen Disaggregation von Stromgrößen und seine Anwendbarkeit auf Immobilienindizes
Albrecht Kauffmann, A. Nastansky
Statistische Diskussionsbeiträge der Wirtschafts- und Sozialwissenschaftlichen Fakultät, Universität Potsdam, Nr. 22,
No. 22,
2006
Abstract
Das Geschehen auf den regional sehr heterogenen Immobilienmärkten ist vor dem Hintergrund stark steigender Preise für Wohn- und Gewerbeimmobilien in den letzten Jahren in weiten Teilen Europas und der Welt stärker ins das Blickfeld der Allgemeinheit sowie der wirtschaftspolitisch Handelnden, insbesondere der Zentralbank, gerückt. Mit einem Anteil von rund 50% nimmt das in Immobilien gebundene Vermögen eine dominierende Stellung im Brutto-Volksvermögen der privaten Haushalte in Deutschland ein. Schwankungen im Wert dieses Eigentums beeinflussen das Verhalten der Haushalte auf den Faktor- und Gütermärkten. So können Vermögenseffekte – hervorgerufen durch steigende oder fallende Immobilienpreise – den Konjunkturverlauf über die Konsumnachfrage positiv wie negativ stimulieren. Überdies kann die Stabilität des Finanzsystems infolge übermäßiger Bewegungen in den Immobilienpreisen und damit einhergehenden Forderungsausfällen von Hypothekendarlehen gefährdet werden. Angesichts der herausragenden volkswirtschaftlichen Bedeutung zeichnet sich jedoch der deutsche Immobilienmarkt auf Grund eines fehlenden amtlichen Berichtssystems durch eine geringe Transparenz aus. Die amtliche Statistik beschränkt sich auf die Erhebung und Veröffentlichung von Preisen für Bauland, Baupreise für Wohngebäude sowie die Mietpreisentwicklung von Wohnimmobilien. Privatwirtschaftliche Institutionen versuchen diese Nische durch die Erhebung eigener Daten und Veröffentlichung von Indizes zu besetzen. Ein Index, der das Preisgeschehen auf den Wohn- und Gewerbeimmobilienmärkten in Deutschland auch unterjährig abbildet, fehlt aber weiterhin.
Die temporale Disaggregation von Jahresdaten kann mittels Regression auf Zeitreihen, die die geforderte Periodizität aufweisen, erfolgen. Soll aber auf die Zuhilfenahme weiterer Daten verzichtet werden, bieten sich deterministische Verfahren an. Diesen sind auch die kubischen Splines zuzurechnen, deren Verwendung in der Literatur gelegentlich – ohne Erläuterung der Methodik und ohne Diskussion der mit ihrer Anwendung verbundenen Probleme, bzw. entsprechende Verweise auf die existierende Literatur – erwähnt wird.
Read article
What can a town achieve today? Integration, urban regimes, and the acceptance of models
Peter Franz
IWH Discussion Papers,
No. 56,
1997
Abstract
Since 1990, the date of German reunification, urban development and especially the recovery of inner cities in East Germany has been delayed by several factors including real estate restitution claims, inflexible preservation codes for historic buildings, and the shortage of stores for retailers. This blockade situation has resulted in the quick and intensified development of shopping centres as „inner city substitutes“ on the urban periphery. The combined effect of the factors preventing revitalisation strategies and the newly realised and practised potential for autonomous action by the authorities of smaller municipalities was a severe restriction for the governing capacities of the authorities of the larger cities. in regaining their governance capability city governments are dependent on urban groups joining and supporting public developmental strategies. In accordance with Stone (1993) and Stoker and Mossberger (1994) urban groups active in urban development policy can be described as urban regimes. In Germany three types of regimes can be differentiated. The cities differ with respect to the political strength and the forms of coalition and conflict between different urban regimes. Specific conditions in East Germany have led to a special regime constellation with a powerful „conservation regime“ on the one hand and a vivid „globalisation regime“ on the other hand. This conflicting constellation results in a developmental blockade. The hypothesis is that a third regime type, the „local alliance“, is missing and still has to be created by practices such as city marketing and city management. Only when this regime building process has advanced will new constellations of political coalitions and compromise become possible and be able to reduce governance problems of city government in the long run.
Read article
Explaining Regional Disparities in Housing Prices across German Districts
Lars Brausewetter, Stephan L. Thomsen, Johannes Trunzer
IZA Institute of Labor Economics,
March
2022
Abstract
Over the last decade, German housing prices have increased unprecedentedly. Drawing on quality-adjusted housing price data at the district level, we document large and increasing regional disparities: growth rates were higher in 1) the largest seven cities, 2) districts located in the south, and 3) districts with higher initial price levels. Indications of price bubbles are concentrated in the largest cities and in the purchasing market. Prices seem to be driven by the demand side: increasing population density, higher shares of academically educated employees and increasing purchasing power explain our findings, while supply remained relatively constrained in the short term.
Read article