Transparency and Forecasting: The Impact of Conditioning Assumptions on Forecast Accuracy
Katja Heinisch, Christoph Schult, Carola Stapper
Applied Economic Letters,
forthcoming
Abstract
This study investigates the impact of inaccurate assumptions on economic forecast precision. We construct a new dataset comprising an unbalanced panel of annual German GDP forecasts from various institutions, taking into account their underlying assumptions. We explicitly control for different forecast horizons to reflect the information available at the time of release. Our analysis reveals that approximately 75% of the variation in squared forecast errors can be attributed to the variation in squared errors of the initial assumptions. This finding emphasizes the importance of accurate assumptions in economic forecasting and suggests that forecasters should transparently disclose their assumptions to enhance the usefulness of their forecasts in shaping effective policy recommendations.
Read article
Economic Outlook
IWH Economic Outlook 2026 Slight Upturn on the Horizon, Structural Problems Remain December 11, 2025 As the year draws to a close, it remains uncertain whether the German economy…
See page
Monitoring
Monitoring Interim Report We are pleased to announce that the first interim report for the project is now available for publication, offering stakeholders a comprehensive overview…
See page
Board Announcements
Board Announcements June 17, 2025: Feedback First Trial Evaluation May 28, 2025: First Trial Evaluation Mar 27, 2025: IWH Evaluation 2025: Save the Dates Jan 28, 2025: IWH in the…
See page
Anti-Corruption
Prevention of Corruption and Misconduct IWH Anti-corruption Guidelines ( Simone Lösel ) Company Agreement on the Introduction of an Internal Reporting Office for a Whistleblower…
See page
12.03.2024 • 8/2024
Risk in the banking sector: four out of ten top supervisors come from the financial industry
Europe's banks realise excess returns on the stock market when their alumni join the boards of national supervisory authorities. A study by the Halle Institute for Economic Research (IWH) shows that this happens more frequently than previously recognised. The findings indicate a risk to financial stability and call for a more merit-based, transparent appointment of senior regulators.
Michael Koetter
Read
Brown Bag Seminar
Brown Bag Seminar Financial Markets Department The seminar series "Brown Bag Seminar" was offered on a regular basis by members of the Financial Markets department and their…
See page
Logo and Colours
IWH Logo and IWH Colours 1. Logo 1.1 Combined Word Picture Mark 1.2 Reduced Versions 1.2.1 Signet 1.2.2 Horizontal Versions 1.2.3 Negative Versions 2. IWH Colours 1. Logo 1.1…
See page
Staffing Policy
Staffing Policy The aim of the Staffing Policy is to provide a uniform and comprehensible basis for staff appointments at the IWH. It serves to ensure transparency and…
See page
The Disciplining Effect of Supervisory Scrutiny in the EU-wide Stress Test
Christoffer Kok, Carola Müller, Steven Ongena, Cosimo Pancaro
Journal of Financial Intermediation,
January
2023
Abstract
Relying on confidential supervisory data related to the 2016 EU-wide stress test, this paper presents novel empirical evidence that supervisory scrutiny associated to stress testing has a disciplining effect on bank risk. We find that banks that participated in the 2016 EU-wide stress test subsequently reduced their credit risk relative to banks that were not part of this exercise. Relying on new metrics for supervisory scrutiny that measure the quantity, potential impact, and duration of interactions between banks and supervisors during the stress test, we find that the disciplining effect is stronger for banks subject to more intrusive supervisory scrutiny during the exercise. We also find that a strong risk management culture is a prerequisite for the supervisory scrutiny to be effective. Finally, we show that a similar disciplining effect is not exerted neither by higher capital charges nor by more transparency and related market discipline induced by the stress test.
Read article
