Productivity and employment effects of staff participation
Ulrich Blum
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 9,
2006
Abstract
Die Beteiligung der Mitarbeiter am Kapital und der den Erträgen der Unternehmen fand in den vergangenen Monaten eine erhöhte Aufmerksamkeit in der Wirtschaftspresse. Hierfür gibt es eine Reihe von Ursachen: der positive Beitrag zu Produktivität und Beschäftigung, die verbesserte Entlohnung und die erhöhte Motivation der Arbeitnehmer und schließlich die Stabilisierung der Finanzierung vor allem bei mittelständischen Unternehmen vor dem Hintergrund von Basel II, also den Eigenkapitalrichtlinien für Banken, die damit ihre Ausleihungen risikoadäquat bepreisen werden. Unter dem Begriff der Mitarbeiterbeteiligung findet sich eine Fülle alternativer Gestaltungen, die davon abhängen, welche Rechtsform das Unternehmen besitzt, ob nur Erträge ausgeschüttet werden sollen oder ob eine Beteiligung am Kapital – und hier entweder beim Eigen- oder beim Fremdkapital erfolgen soll. Die damit auftretende Fülle von Ausprägungen macht es statistisch enorm schwierig, klare Nachweise für Vorteile zu führen, vor allem aber nachzuweisen, wie die vermuteten Wirkungsmechanismen ablaufen. In diesem Beitrag wird die Relevanz von Mitarbeiterbeteiligungen für den Unternehmenserfolg aus Sicht der Literatur und zwei eigenen Forschungsbeiträgen dargestellt, um Aussagen über deren wirtschaftliche Wirkungen zu gewinnen und abzuleiten, ob sie grundsätzlich geeignet sind, Arbeitnehmer an Erträge aus Wissen und Kapital heranzuführen. Tatsächlich läßt sich zeigen, daß die Strukturen von Unternehmen mit Mitarbeiterbeteiligungen, vor allem im Mittelstand, erheblich von denen ohne derartige Angebote abweicht. Bei gegebenem Wirtschaftszweig sind sie in erfolgreicheren Märkten tätig als der Durchschnitt der Unternehmen. Die Erfolgsbeiträge bei den Unternehmern sind schwer zu messen, weil sie verteilt werden, und nicht allein als erhöhte Gewinne erscheinen. Vielmehr fließen diese Produktivitätsgewinne auch den Kunden durch verbesserte Qualität zu, was wiederum risikosenkend wirkt, oder sie erhöhen den Wert des Unternehmens.
Read article
Microeconometric Evaluation of Selected ESF-funded ALMP-Programmes
Eva Reinowski, Birgit Schultz
IWH Discussion Papers,
No. 17,
2006
Abstract
The study evaluates different ESF-funded labour market programmes by comparing the labour market status at different points in time after the treatment. In order to solve the selection problem we employ a standard matching algorithm with a multi-dimensional distance measure. The effects of the analyzed programmes (wage subsidies, start-up subsidies and qualification measures for recipients of social welfare) are very heterogeneous. It can be observed that the direct integration into the regular labour market provides an advantage for the supported individuals. Its lasting effects, however, strongly depend on the group of persons being supported, the type of treatment and the employers’ financial share.
Read article
Gesamtwirtschaftliche Effekte der Förderung regenerativer Energien, insbesondere der Biomasse - Eine kritische Beurteilung vor dem Hintergrund modelltheoretischer Konzeptionen
Götz Zeddies
Zeitschrift für Umweltpolitik und Umweltrecht 2/2006,
No. 2,
2006
Abstract
Renewable energies are largely promoted in the Federal Republic of Germany by means of political instruments by the federal government as well as by the federal states. However, the effects of promoting renewable energies on growth and employment are politically controversial. On the part of the scientists, the macroeconomic effects of the promotion of renewable energies were already analysed in different studies by various authors. At first sight, even the scientific results do not allow definite conclusions. The reasons for this may be seen in the diversity of the applied empirical methods and models with respect to their closeness and the model assumptions. Against the background of these difficulties, the aim of this paper is to discuss the general problems of macroeconomic policy analyses, to formulate methodical model requirements and to examine important existing scientific studies with respect to these requirements and to evaluate their results.
Read article
Sind ältere Beschäftigte weniger produktiv? Eine empirische Analyse anhand des LIAB
Lutz Schneider
IWH Discussion Papers,
No. 13,
2006
Abstract
Against the background of an aging labor force in Germany and insufficient job chances of elders the paper rises the question, whether various age groups differ in their productivity levels. The analysis is carried out on the basis of a new linked employer-employee dataset for the years of 2000 and 2003. With respect to the manufacturing sector the cross section regressions provide unambiguous evidence for a higher productivity of mid-age-workers. In contrast the effects regarding the service sector turn out to be of less significance.
Read article
Who Invests in Training if Contracts are Temporary? - Empirical Evidence for Germany Using Selection Correction
Jan Sauermann
IWH Discussion Papers,
No. 14,
2006
Abstract
This study deals with the effect of fixed-term contracts on work-related training. Though previous studies found a negative effect of fixed-term contracts on the participation in training, from the theoretical point of view it is not clear whether workers with fixed-term contracts receive less or more training, compared to workers with permanent contracts. In addition to the existing strand of literature, we especially distinguish between employer- and employee-financed training in order to allow for diverging investment patterns of worker and firm. Using data from the German Socio-Economic Panel (GSOEP), we estimate a bivariate probit model to control for selection effects that may arise from unobservable factors, affecting both participation in training and holding fixed-term contracts. Finding negative effects for employer-sponsored, as well as for employee-sponsored training, leads us to conclude that workers with fixed-term contracts do not compensate for lower firm investments.
Read article
IWH industry survey East Germany, beginning of 2006: turnover prospects also without effects on employment in 2006
Sophie Wörsdorfer
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 3,
2006
Abstract
Das Verarbeitende Gewerbe entwickelte sich im Jahr 2005 bei einem Umsatzzuwachs von 6,9% gegenüber 2004 deutlich günstiger als die ostdeutsche Wirtschaft insgesamt. Die konjunkturelle Erholung der Industrie schlägt sich auch in der guten Ertragslage der Betriebe nieder: drei von fünf Unternehmen schrieben im vergangenen Jahr Gewinne. Dabei befindet sich ein besonders hoher Anteil an erfolgreichen Unternehmen unter den Exporteuren, von denen ca. 67% das Jahr 2005 mit Gewinn abschlossen. Für dieses Jahr erwartet das Gros, d. h. mehr als zwei von drei Firmen, einen Anstieg der Umsätze. Insgesamt veranschlagten die Unternehmen ein Umsatzplus von 2,5%. Die Erwartungen dürften aber eher den unteren Rand des Möglichen kennzeichnen. Trotz der Umsatzsteigerung ist keine Entspannung am Arbeitsmarkt in Sicht. Dort, wo für 2006 positive Zuwachsraten beim Umsatz veranschlagt werden, ist in lediglich 38% der Fälle auch eine Personalaufstockung beabsichtigt. Insgesamt wird es keinen Aufbau der Beschäftigung geben: so steht einer leichten Aufstockung der Beschäftigtenzahl im Investitionsgütergewerbe (+4%) die Reduzierung des Personalbestands in der Konsumgüterindustrie gegenüber (-5,6%). In diesem Zusammenhang dürften sowohl Produktivitätsreserven als auch Kündigungsmodalitäten sowie die Langfristigkeit der Personalplanung eine Rolle spielen.
Read article
Determinants of employment - the macroeconomic view
Christian Dreger, Heinz P. Galler, Ulrich (eds) Walwai
Schriften des IWH,
No. 22,
2005
Abstract
The weak performance of the German labour market over the past years has led to a significant unemployment problem. Currently, on average 4.5 mio. people are without a job contract, and a large part of them are long-term unemployed. A longer period of unemployment reduces their employability and aggravates the problem of social exclusion.
The factors driving the evolution of employment have been recently discussed on the workshop Determinanten der Beschäftigung – die makroökonomische Sicht organized jointly by the IAB, Nuremberg, and the IWH, Halle. The present volume contains the papers and proceedings to the policy oriented workshop held in November 2004, 15-16th. The main focus of the contributions is twofold. First, macroeconomic conditions to stimulate output and employment are considered. Second, the impacts of the increasing tax wedge between labour costs and the take home pay are emphasized. In particular, the role of the contributions to the social security system is investigated.
In his introductory address, Ulrich Walwei (IAB) links the unemployment experience to the modest path of economic growth in Germany. In addition, the low employment intensity of GDP growth and the temporary standstill of the convergence process of the East German economy have contributed to the weak labour market performance. In his analysis, Gebhard Flaig (ifo Institute, München) stresses the importance of relative factor price developments. A higher rate of wage growth leads to a decrease of the employment intensity of production, and correspondingly to an increase of the threshold of employment. Christian Dreger (IWH) discusses the relevance of labour market institutions like employment protection legislation and the structure of the wage bargaining process on the labour market outcome. Compared to the current setting, policies should try to introduce more flexibility in labour markets to improve the employment record. The impact of interest rate shocks on production is examined by the paper of Boris Hofmann (Deutsche Bundesbank, Frankfurt). According to the empirical evidence, monetary policy cannot explain the modest economic performance in Germany. György Barabas and Roland Döhrn (RWI Essen) have simulated the effects of a world trade shock on output and employment. The relationships have been fairly stable over the past years, even in light of the increasing globalization. Income and employment effects of the German tax reform in 2000 are discussed by Peter Haan and Viktor Steiner (DIW Berlin). On the base of a microsimulation model, household gains are determined. Also, a positive relationship between wages and labour supply can be established. Michael Feil und Gerd Zika (IAB) have examined the employment effects of a reduction of the contribution rates to the social security system. To obtain robust results, the analysis is done under alternative financing scenarios and with different macroeconometric models. The impacts of allowances of social security contributions on the incentives to work are discussed by Wolfgang Meister and Wolfgang Ochel (ifo München). According to their study, willingness to work is expected to increase especially at the lower end of the income distribution. The implied loss of contributions could be financed by higher taxes.
Read article
The coalition treaty from a fiscal point of view
Kristina vanDeuverden
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 12,
2005
Abstract
After weeks of negotiations the coalition finally agreed on the conditions for their political work. Not surprisingly, the coalition agreement is complex and intransparent – with a multitude of single measures far away from a precise definition. Quantifying the programme and estimating resulting cash flows is currently difficult; official calculations are – if at all – only partly available. Anyhow, the contract will form the basis for economic policy during the next four years; therefore its evaluation by now is indispensable. The thin red line of the agreement – not astonishingly when considering the precarious financial situation of the public sector – is consolidation. However, more than 80% of the consolidation volume results from the revenue side. Though one third of this is due to the cutback of tax exemptions, the lion’s share comes from raising tax rates, mainly the VAT standard rate. In contrast, cutting back public expenditure is minor and the agreement clearly comes short of the Koch/Steinbrück proposal; even new tax reliefs are created. The consolidation is almost completely borne by private households. Enterprises as a whole are barely hit. However, they have to wait until 2008 for a reform of company taxation – one of the most pressing problems in this legislative period. To reduce the companies tax burden until the reform starts the conditions for tax depreciation are temporarily relaxed. Anyway, from an international point of view the statutory tax rate is an important signal to enterprises deciding where to invest. Lowering effective tax rates by changing depreciation conditions is intransparent and, thus, will be less effective. Furthermore savings within the public sector are planned to accomplish consolidation; 10 billion Euro should result from efficiency gains and reduced expenditure. Consolidation measures mainly focus on the budget of the federal government. However, Länder and communities will participate in the additional tax revenues. In contrast, social securities will loose – and therefore also the share of employment that is subject to social insurance contribution. Particularly the unemployment insurance will be burdened by the decrease of its premium rate. Besides, the federal government will reduce its grants to the pension funds and most notably the health system. The contract is dominated by fiscal constraints. Cyclical requirements are considered only cursory and pressing structural reforms are put off. The reforms of company’s taxation, of fiscal federalism, of the health system as well as a proceeding reform of the labour market are only proposed. How and when measures in these fields are realised will determine whether fiscal policy can set a new course.
Read article
Is co-determination economically reasonable? East German manufacturing and construction as examples
Birgit Schultz
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 9,
2005
Abstract
In the public discussion there are controversial argumentations how works worker’s participation in form of work council in questions of office politics and economic interests. Theoretical publications of this topic show mainly positive effects for staff and management. Therefore we analyse the effects of work council for chances in employment. In establishments with a positive result situation at the status quo and a work council we found a positive trend on employment and the future result. Compared to primarily prosperous establishments without staff association downgrade their result situation. In case of negative result situation establishments with a work council have no greater problems to reduce the employment than establishments without a work council.
Read article
The Impact of Institutions on the Employment Performance in European Labour Markets
Herbert S. Buscher, Christian Dreger, Raúl Ramos, Jordi Surinach
Discussion Paper No. 1732,
2005
Abstract
The paper investigates the role of institutions for labor market performance across European countries. As participation rates have been rather stable over the past, the unemployment problem is mainly caused by shortages in labor demand. Labor demand is expressed by its structural parameters, such as the elasticities of employment to output and factor prices. Institutional variables include employment protection legislation, the structure of wage bargaining, measures describing the tax and transfer system and active labor market policies. As cointegration between employment, output and factor prices is detected, labor demand equations are fitted in levels by efficient estimation techniques. Then, labor demand elasticities are explained by institutions using panel fixed effects regressions. The results suggest that higher flexibility and incentives of households to work appear to be appropriate strategies to improve the employment record. The employment response to economic conditions is stronger in a more deregulated environment, and the absorption of shocks can be relieved.
Read article